Monday, August 2, 2010

Papa Pilgrim

http://mccarthy-kennicott.com/MJ2003/page2.html

Alaska is known for its interesting people. This is just one link about an interesting man and his family I mentioned briefly with a couple class members. Originally he was idolized for his "family values". Eventually his ethics were brought to light and dealt with. Several of the family members continue to have problems with the justice system.

current and proposed N. Slope and Pebble Mine maps and awesome link regarding anwr

http://akcenter.org/gis/map-gallery

http://www.anwr.org/features/politics/whouse.htm

Saturday, July 31, 2010

Alaska indigenous Land Claims

http://www.unesco.org/csi/LINKS/monaco-ppts/McClintock_ppt_MonacoUNESCOarctic.pdf

I found this PDF when I was doing research for the final project.

There's some awesome pictures in this PDF, especially the picture of Kivalina.

^_^

Friday, July 30, 2010

http://www.newsminer.com/pages/full_story/push?article-Alaska+Board+of+Game+votes+to+double+permits+for+Nelchina+caribou+hunt%20&id=8939760&instance=h

This is link discussing a recent decision to increase the number of tier 1 permits in a given area. There are comments from ADF&G and the Ahtna. The discussion gets better after you get past the background part of the story. Most of the comments in response to the article are rediculous but always entertaining to read.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Preserving language

This is of course my own opinion but I do invite others to sway my thinking in another direction. Learning is a continuous experience. Feel free to flame me or educate me as appropriate. I am interested in hearing from others. Which of course is the reason to blog!

I am looking forward to hearing what Kalesha has to say. I was interested in learning the response but was discouraged when the answer was not revealed with a scholarly reason.

Kalesha's question was consistently redirected for reason of pride. Pride is not necessarily a bad thing but it is a selfish act that is defended in order to validate oneself. This in itself is neither bad nor good but it must be recognized. To ethically monitor yourself and be aware of your own identity will allow you to understand all related bias. It is this understanding that is the purpose of advancing education. It is human nature to protect and promote your own bias but it must be understood that you may be wrong even though your are being true to yourself. Different perspective is the only true understanding.

The analogy of killing a panda or an atomic bomb versus bows and arrows are analogies that do not relate. Written language has little establishment in human nature as a whole. I would offer that spoken language is part of identity but to lose it does not mean the end of a population or even individual identity. If losing the ability to speak one specific language was detrimental to identity there would be alot of lost souls in the world.

I did find the speaker and information to be interesting but knowing the "why" of preserving language over another was NOT answered. Granted, the way Alaska native language was taken is not right, however; the preservation of a language in order to justify saving a culture is not a good argument. This is especially true when it is a forced requirement. Progress is inevitable in human nature. This should be apparant to any cognitive mind.

photo essay or rural life

Here is a link to the Anchorage Daily News with a phote essay of rural life.

http://www.adn.com/2009/03/12/721082/life-in-rural-alaska.html

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Time for me is up.

It is 11:57 I am off to my Psychology class. If anyone posts a new blog between now and 2:00 I can not comment on it.

The New Migrants

Alaska Native Claims/Alaska Natives and Their Lands (Ch 10)

When the Russians first came over to look for furs, they found the Aleuts living off the land in a peaceful setting. The Aleuts welcomed them as most all the natives did and the Russian (Barbarians) Trappers took full advantage of their hospitality. They wanted fur bearing animals such as the seal and the prized beaver pelts. They overtook and/or killed the men and took away their women and all their possessions and made them into slaves to hunt for them. (Peter Kostromitin, Makushin, 1878)

The Natives (uncivilized tribes) were unaware of the fact that the Russians had claimed ownership of their lands and most were even unaware of the fact that their land was sold to the United States. They were referred to the name “uncivilized tribes” in the Treaty of the United States. The US Army moved to Sitka where Russia had been posted right after the sale.

The Tlingit chiefs heard about the sale of their lands to the United States by the Russians and talked with the officials. They told them they did not give the permission to the Russians to sell their lands. They had only allowed the Russians the right to hunt or buy their furs. Their land had belonged to their forefathers and was not for sale, but it was already too late. The Americans couldn’t turn back on the deal they made or retrieve their money from the Russians.

Eventually two Tlingit men were killed by the soldiers. According to their way of law, the Tlingit demanded a settlement but nothing happened to repay for the lives lost. They retaliated by killing two white people. (then the Military wipes out a whole village!) The actions of the soldiers and the United States makes me wonder what would have been better for the natives in Alaska of the two evils?

If the Russians stayed, would the Natives have been worse off or better? The Russians established a Fort at Sitka and had a church run by the Archbishop Veniaminov. He taught in the language of the people and did not discourage them from learning in their language. (Of course, my bias is for language preservation) By that time the Russians and Tlingits were becoming more aquainted, so why did they sell off the land? The United States on the other hand wanted to civilize the Natives who they claimed were a part of the plants and fauna, not even human. They wanted to teach them to speak English because they couldn’t understand their languages, so then began the long drawn out saga of destruction for the Native people of Alaska.

(I hope the personal comments I made has not offended anyone. It is not meant to offend, but to share my opinions and bias.)

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

The Battle Over Who Gets What

I have to say, first, that this is a lot of information to take in and digest in a short period of time. There are so many complicated factors involved. I feel that no matter what decisions get made, Alaska will never be what it once was. Modern progress continues to weave its way through Alaska. I mourn for those who have had their cherished way of life ripped away from them. How does one successfully live in two worlds at the same time? Very few places if any, I presume, exist where life is lived completely in the old ways. Modern conveniences can make life easier in some respects, but it creates dependence on a cash economy. It seems like subsistence living has gone, for many, from being a pure means of survival to being a means of continuing a traditional way of life while, at the same time, being a way to earn money to pay for modern conveniences. What choice is there? How do people successfully move forward without letting go of their heritage, cultural identity?

As we discussed in class, regional corporations are given the responsibility to invest in way that will bring the greatest returns to its shareholders. Does money cure what ails? It may for some. For others it does more harm that good. In a perfect world those who want to continue to live the way they have for generations upon generations would be left to do so, undisturbed. In the real, savage world we live in its every man for himself so to speak. Those who have power decide the fate of others. Even those who start with the best intentions cannot fulfill the wants and needs of everyone.

So what is my point? Human beings have done great harm to other human beings by trying to civilize them. Nothing will truly make up for what has been lost. It is my opinion that regardless of what they agree to the Federal Government can do pretty much whatever it wants to. If the land was taken before it can be taken again. That is not to say that people should not continue to fight for what they feel is right, but there is probably never going to be an end to those battles.

"Reservation or No Reservations

" Reservations or No Reservations"

The "ANCSA"was a well written documents second to the Alaskan Constitution over statehood fighting for the protection, management, and right to a fair economic system to support Alaskans.
After reading sections of this document I feel that if the Native people would have continue down the path of establishing more reservations this would have been disastrous for many tribes over the years. When oil was discovered in Alaska 1968, Congress did not want any more reservation because it would be a lenghty court proceeding over Native Claims and tie up oil companies, unions,constructions, so the pipeline could not be built. In my opinion, this gave the native people an advantage along with Congress in getting the Alaska Native Claims Settlement Act passed.
Many Alaskan Native leaders and AFN were opposed to reservations and reserves. They felt being a corporation would give them more control of their own destiny. Before 1971, when Native Indians Land was controlled by the government under Bureau of Indians Affairs on reservations. There was a lot of corruptions within the agencies, money allocated for American Indians was benefiting others, sale of mineral and timber contract was far below market value on tribal land. A lot of the land was miss used by the government employees and lucrative for many of the exploratory companies. The native people received very little revenue for their land.
The push from Congress and ANCSA helped develop the 13 Regional Corporations. This new approach gave Alaskan Native sole control of their land and money without BIA involvement.
Some thought if the land was turned over to a traditional government, become a reservation, the BIA might get control of it again. What do you think would have happen?

BS

Oops! Future Generations: The Missing Piece in the ANCSA Pie?

After reading the articles and reviewing the history behind the ANCSA legislation, this piece of legislation seems to have created a win-win situation for all parties involved. The politics of ANCSA gave the Federal government an out from the establishment of additional Native Alaskan reservations. The logistics of the corporation approach to ANCSA was a push to appease the Native Alaskans represented by the momentous Alaskan Federation of Natives (AFN). Governmental constituents realizing there was a need to quickly produce a land settlement piece in order to capitalize on the rich natural land reserves, oil, mineral resources and bountiful wildlife, fish and game. Reaching this collective agreement in an expedient manner would certainly satisfy the interests of the big three: conservationalist, big oil industrialist, and professional politicians. Because of the need for speed in passing this legislation, written in the original ANCSA documentation was the royal shafting of generations of Alaska Natives born after December 18, 1971, namely the "New Natives." Was this a political oversight or intended incongruity?

Monday, July 26, 2010

Long-winded ramble forces me to make uncomfortable conclusion

Disclaimer.
I don't necessarily believe in all or any of the ideas in this blog post. I'm playing devil's advocate. My primary objectives are to provoke thought and force people to justify their convictions. Please remember that no offense is intended.

Ramble.
Many of Alaska's first white settlers regarded the indigenous tribes of the region as a relatively homogeneous race of savages, not akin to true citizens of America in any significant way. The settlers' misunderstandings of the original inhabitants of the state have become common knowledge, and most people today consider it deplorable that a better understanding was not established between the two groups of people.

I've been aware of these bigoted attitudes for a long time. But something new struck me as I browsed through the paper written by William Hensley and the Alaska Native Land Claims e-book. The language of this early legislation portrays the natives not necessarily as an inferior race, but as a childlike one which is earlier along the route towards maturation. According to the verdict of United States v. Cadzow, for instance, which Hensley cites in his paper, "the uncivilized native tribes of Alaska are wards of the government; [and the] United States has the right, and [the] duty, to protect the property rights of its Indian wards" (emphasis added). The term "ward" is often used to describe people (especially minors) who are dependent on others for their welfare. The implication in this clause seems to be that natives were helpless without the U.S. government.

Alaska's indigenous tribes, of course, never consented to being adopted either by the United States or Russia. The thousands of years that indigenous people flourished in Alaska before the conquest of the white man makes it abundantly clear that they were capable of providing for themselves, even though their conception of civilization differed from Western ideals.

But according to Cadzow, in addition to a number of other documents from the same time period (see the letter from the Office of the Solicitor in Chapter 12 of the Alaskool e-book, for instance), the U.S. government voluntarily shouldered the responsibility of protecting the natives and helping them to achieve maturity as full-fledged citizens of the United States. Only civilized, grown-up natives would, according to Article 3 of the Treaty of Cession, "be admitted to the enjoyment of all the rights, advantages, and immunities of citizens of the United States."

The implicit supposition in this attitude toward the "immature" native tribes is that progress is linear and unidirectional. This view holds that the tribe's abandonment of their "barbaric" cultural practices and their assimilation into the relatively homogeneous society of the United States were definitely steps in the right direction. The adult society inducted the childlike society into adulthood.

Is it really the case that the United States' industrial development and civilization made it the more grown-up of the two conflicting societies? In other words, would the Alaskan natives, given enough time, have made the same technological innovations and discoveries as the progress-driven white folks, thereby embarking on the same path toward societal maturity? Or is it possible that the progress of different peoples across the globe does not converge on a single, one-way vector, but actually diverges along any number of paths toward societal actualization?

I think that most people's gut response to this question would be that Alaskan natives were just as sophisticated as the Russians and Americans who colonized their land, and that it was therefore ridiculous for the U.S. government to act as some kind of adopted big brother or father to the natives without their invitation.

But the question is not as straightforward as it might seem. We must remember that our instinctive reactions to questions of cultural supremacy are as much a byproduct of our education and background nowadays as they were a century ago. As the European settlers were taught that their nations and culture were superior to those of the aboriginal tribes, so most Americans today are taught that different peoples and cultural practices are fundamentally equal. Like our forerunners, we are a product of our times. We don't know the absolute truth of the matter any more than they did.

We should also remember that most societies in Eurasia developed along somewhat parallel paths for thousands of years, more or less independently of one another. All across the Old World, and even in Mesoamerican societies in the New World, tribes of people eventually abandoned their subsistence lifestyle, developed a sustainable form of agriculture, and settled down in one place. These small settlements gradually grew and merged together to form towns and cities. The rest is history.

Outside of southeast Alaska, however, most natives lived off the land, traveling seasonally between a number of campsites rather than living in one place year-round. Given enough time undisturbed by colonists, would the natives have eventually embraced sedentary agriculture and urbanization like the rest of the world? Or would they maintain their traditional ways?

At least in its southcentral and interior regions, Alaska contains large tracts of fertile land. It's conceivable that natives eventually would have cultivated these lands if it were not for the intrusion of white settlers. Moreover, since agriculture has always been the impetus for a nomadic band to settle down in one place, natives would probably have abandoned their hunter-gatherer ways if this had occurred.

This train of reasoning seems to illustrate a developmental trajectory similar to that of many other early human civilizations.

The logical conclusion of these premises is that, prior to the arrival of American settlers, native Alaskans were at an earlier point along the path of societal development than the Europeans. The settlers who imperiously adopted the indigenous peoples as their "wards," and gave lip-service, at least, to the idea of integrating them into mainstream American society, truly were the adults in the partnership.

Note that this conclusion does not say anything about the inherent superiority of one race over another. It simply acknowledges that there is a certain justification in the language of the legal documents cited above.

What was lost, perhaps, when white settlers invaded Alaska was not the possibility of preserving the natives' age-old civilization, but rather their self-determination---the opportunity to travel along the same path as Europe and the rest of the world without being prematurely dragged forward.

This conclusion is rather troublesome to me, as I believe that all peoples are fundamentally equal, and the acknowledgment that Alaskan natives were, in some respects, at an earlier stage of civilization than the American settlers seems to be a sign of creeping racism. Please save me from my logic. I invite you to poke holes in my argument. Have fun.

(Please remember, of course, that I am playing devil's advocate.)

ANCSA

I found it interesting that one of the readings had mentioned William Hensley, from Kotzebue. I've learned that he was one of the founders of Alaska Federation of Natives, and ANCSA. Reading how he grew up not being able to learn about his own cultures history and traditions, made me wonder how people were chosen to become one of the spokes men for their people. When it was time for Alaska Natives to choose where their land was located, who where the people that decided where the border line was? How were those people chosen to do that job?
I also was wondering about the education system. Yes children were sent out to boarding schools, then people started to stand up for having local schools in rural villages. How did that go about? Now every Alaskan Native has the same rights as every other American. They have the right to an education. Like we were talking in class on how if they don't have more then ten students the school is shut down. It make me think of how in college they allow distance courses. How some classes are paper based, and how that might be able to apply to k-12 education. Do they allow that to take place, or do they just leave the nine students that were left with their school getting shut down, to try and get their own education?

Assignment Extension

Given that we are not where anticipated with regard to content at this point the assignment is hereby extended until Wednesday, July 26 at 1:59 pm.

Over the next 2.25 days please read your classmates posts carefully and provide feedback that relates back to the articles, or the content of the law or your experiences you might draw upon.


dave.

The "have" and "have not" Alaska Natives

According to the article about ANCSA, "As the law now stands, there is a split between the 'have' and 'have not' Alaska Natives." Since only those Alaska Natives born on or before December 18, 1971 were eligible to receive stock, it was reported that by 1991 over 50% of Alaska Natives may not be shareholders. This fact surprised me. Given the importance of the land to maintain their traditional lifestyle, I believe this is an unforseen effect of the provisions in ANCSA. I believe it was the intent of the Alaska Native people, to insure through this claims act, that the land and stock provided in the agreement would always be there to sustain them. While the "New Natives", as they are referred to in the article, will be able to inherit stock and purchase stock (when and if it becomes available), those who are not Alaska Native will be able to purchase the stock as well. As the population of Alaska Natives born on or before December 18, 1971 declines, how will the language in ANCSA that created the "have" and "have not" Alaska Natives impact the stock and land ownership? Should this issue be addressed soon? If so, by whom?
Mary

Do the Native Alaska Deserve land ?

I am wondering if there is a word “own” in Native Alaska language. They live in this land, don’t have the sense to own the land, or any other resources. They only share the land, and only take the resources on the land for living purpose.

US government used the similar methed to solve the Native Land Problem as when they deal with the Native Indian People. On the excuse of improve the living quality of Native Indian People, forcing the tribes division all the land to individuals, and sold the rest to whites, which resulted the disintegration of social structures of native Indian people.

For the ANCSA, the only difference is the Native Alaskan get much more land than Native Indian due to their special lifestyle.

I just think the issue is not the land, but their lifestyle. They don’t care the land is under Russia or America as long their way of life is not disturbed. They don’t deserve land, they just want to maintain the way of their lives.

Gimme some slack: I'm not lazy, I'm slow.

Earlier today, I had the best intentions of writing a post tonight. But now, as of ten minutes to one, I know that is impossible. Anything that comes out of my head in my current state of exhaustion, after I've toiled over the articles for far longer than the three hours I anticipated, is bound to be incomprehensible. Therefore I promise to hammer out a couple of paragraphs in the early morning tomorrow (today!), so you will have plenty of time to comment on my post before class.

In order to determine the approximate amount of time that it will take me to read a given piece in the future, I will multiply Professor Veazey's estimation by 2.5.

G'nite.

Corporations

The Readings

The Alaska Native Claims Association (ANCSA) readings.

In January 2010, the Supreme Court expanded the definition of “person” to include corporations. This controversial ruling eases restrictions on corporations contributing unlimited amounts of money to general, state and local elections. The controversy comes from the fact that corporate interests could outspend legitimate candidates, or promote candidates who will serve the interests of the corporation, and or create an incentive for candidates to appeal to corporations to “elect” them instead of their constitutes in home districts.

The ANCSA reading included a paragraph on corporations:

“The concept or idea of a corporation is often difficult to grasp. We may know one when we see it, but describing one can be confounding. The above definition can be more easily understood, if it is reversed and we think of a corporation as a person. In many respects, the law treats corporations like persons. Like any other "person," a corporation can apply for and receive credit from a bank. A corporation has a "birth certificate" in the form of its charter, which is issued by the state. The "birth certificate" or charter gives a place and time of birth. Unlike a person, a corporation does not have to die. It can "live on" indefinitely. "Death" occurs only when assets (if any) are sold and the corporation is dissolved.”

I would have to disagree that a corporation is anything like a person on one major bases, that the separate legal entity that a corporation is, is designed so that shareholders are not personally responsible for the corporations liabilities and debts. A person, in its traditional sense, is responsible for its liabilities and debts.

I personally found this subject the most interesting segment of the reading, just because in some cases in the country corporations were seen as a “person”. Now the Supreme Court’s decision uniformly makes all corporations “persons”. And as if big corporations are not already embedded into the law making process (Congress), corporations are now allowed to buy our elections.

Over all, my beef with this ruling has nothing to do with the ANCSA and their corporations, in terms of the reading. I am actually indifferent to corporations in general, but against the notion that they are “people” or “persons”.

I also noticed the debate over who should be able to form a corporation. In chapter 20 of the Alaskcool readings, the debate over whether or not Alaska Natives should have the ability to create and maintain corporations goes against the pro-capitalist, pro-business mentality that so many republican and conservative politians argue for. Opposing this option for Native peoples, conservative Congressman Wayne Aspinall of Colorado suggested that Congress should not allow this power to Natives because of the "lack of democratic controls in a large corporation, particularly with unsophisticated people." Clearly the issue was race, and not business. But I am impressed that Congress was able to push through this landmark Legislation that it did, even if it did take over several years.

Sunday, July 25, 2010

THE ALASKAN NATIVE AND THE TREATY OF CESSION, 1867

This reading did not give me the feeling of satisfaction at how far we have come as a country and as a state in the last 143 years since we purchased Alaska, I would say I have more of a disgraceful feeling when it comes to this country. We had already officially been the U.S. for 91 years when we bought the Alaskan territory, and we still were handling the Native people the same way we always had by showing up, claiming their land, and telling them they need to become "civilized". Alaska was and still is a huge area with lots of natural resources, and I think today we have only moved from being less forceful and openly cruel to understanding and dealing with people such as the Alaska Natives better so that we can still use their resources for the same profitable reasons while not looking like the bad guys.
Failing to recognize the simple fact that we all just happen to be different was a huge complication for Alaska and it's early policies of dealing with the Natives because we treated them the same throughout the whole territory causing the destruction of some ways of life. Although things have been worked out in Alaska regarding citizenship for Natives and some reparations, there are still problems here from what we have done in the past and I think dealing with these problems should be more of a concern than they currently are. Obviously things can't go back to the way they were but I don't think we should forget how we changed them and what we can do to really do help to Alaskan communities.

Errors in Fundamental Planning by US Government

The one message I have taken away from this reading is that the United States seems to have a terrible track record when it comes to making decisions affecting the Native people. They thought that the entire population of Native Alaskans lived in "fixed abodes" based on the small amount of knowledge they had from Tlingit-Haida Natives living in Southeast Alaska. The fact was that many of the Western and Northern natives, such as the Eskimo, were migratory.
Another embarrassing example of the American judgement system in Alaska is Project Chariot. Project Chariot was the idea of setting off a nuclear device(?!) in order to create a harbor near Cape Thompson to ship minerals. One can only imagine the implications such an act could have had on the local wildlife Natives relied on. While I do believe that this project could have had positive effects the fact still remains that the government made no effort to consult the local Natives. It's not hard for me to understand why many natives were opposed to ANCSA when even up to the Statehood movement many Natives were not even aware that their homeland was under American ownership. When someone comes into your homeland and tells you, "Ok, well, we actually own this land so were going to dig holes in the ground and disrupt the entire ecosystem but don't worry you might get some money out of it." This is one of those sensitive issues for me when it comes to American history, as far back as it goes little has changed when it comes to original inhabitants of "American" soil.