Saturday, July 31, 2010

Alaska indigenous Land Claims

http://www.unesco.org/csi/LINKS/monaco-ppts/McClintock_ppt_MonacoUNESCOarctic.pdf

I found this PDF when I was doing research for the final project.

There's some awesome pictures in this PDF, especially the picture of Kivalina.

^_^

Friday, July 30, 2010

http://www.newsminer.com/pages/full_story/push?article-Alaska+Board+of+Game+votes+to+double+permits+for+Nelchina+caribou+hunt%20&id=8939760&instance=h

This is link discussing a recent decision to increase the number of tier 1 permits in a given area. There are comments from ADF&G and the Ahtna. The discussion gets better after you get past the background part of the story. Most of the comments in response to the article are rediculous but always entertaining to read.

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Preserving language

This is of course my own opinion but I do invite others to sway my thinking in another direction. Learning is a continuous experience. Feel free to flame me or educate me as appropriate. I am interested in hearing from others. Which of course is the reason to blog!

I am looking forward to hearing what Kalesha has to say. I was interested in learning the response but was discouraged when the answer was not revealed with a scholarly reason.

Kalesha's question was consistently redirected for reason of pride. Pride is not necessarily a bad thing but it is a selfish act that is defended in order to validate oneself. This in itself is neither bad nor good but it must be recognized. To ethically monitor yourself and be aware of your own identity will allow you to understand all related bias. It is this understanding that is the purpose of advancing education. It is human nature to protect and promote your own bias but it must be understood that you may be wrong even though your are being true to yourself. Different perspective is the only true understanding.

The analogy of killing a panda or an atomic bomb versus bows and arrows are analogies that do not relate. Written language has little establishment in human nature as a whole. I would offer that spoken language is part of identity but to lose it does not mean the end of a population or even individual identity. If losing the ability to speak one specific language was detrimental to identity there would be alot of lost souls in the world.

I did find the speaker and information to be interesting but knowing the "why" of preserving language over another was NOT answered. Granted, the way Alaska native language was taken is not right, however; the preservation of a language in order to justify saving a culture is not a good argument. This is especially true when it is a forced requirement. Progress is inevitable in human nature. This should be apparant to any cognitive mind.

photo essay or rural life

Here is a link to the Anchorage Daily News with a phote essay of rural life.

http://www.adn.com/2009/03/12/721082/life-in-rural-alaska.html

Wednesday, July 28, 2010

Time for me is up.

It is 11:57 I am off to my Psychology class. If anyone posts a new blog between now and 2:00 I can not comment on it.

The New Migrants

Alaska Native Claims/Alaska Natives and Their Lands (Ch 10)

When the Russians first came over to look for furs, they found the Aleuts living off the land in a peaceful setting. The Aleuts welcomed them as most all the natives did and the Russian (Barbarians) Trappers took full advantage of their hospitality. They wanted fur bearing animals such as the seal and the prized beaver pelts. They overtook and/or killed the men and took away their women and all their possessions and made them into slaves to hunt for them. (Peter Kostromitin, Makushin, 1878)

The Natives (uncivilized tribes) were unaware of the fact that the Russians had claimed ownership of their lands and most were even unaware of the fact that their land was sold to the United States. They were referred to the name “uncivilized tribes” in the Treaty of the United States. The US Army moved to Sitka where Russia had been posted right after the sale.

The Tlingit chiefs heard about the sale of their lands to the United States by the Russians and talked with the officials. They told them they did not give the permission to the Russians to sell their lands. They had only allowed the Russians the right to hunt or buy their furs. Their land had belonged to their forefathers and was not for sale, but it was already too late. The Americans couldn’t turn back on the deal they made or retrieve their money from the Russians.

Eventually two Tlingit men were killed by the soldiers. According to their way of law, the Tlingit demanded a settlement but nothing happened to repay for the lives lost. They retaliated by killing two white people. (then the Military wipes out a whole village!) The actions of the soldiers and the United States makes me wonder what would have been better for the natives in Alaska of the two evils?

If the Russians stayed, would the Natives have been worse off or better? The Russians established a Fort at Sitka and had a church run by the Archbishop Veniaminov. He taught in the language of the people and did not discourage them from learning in their language. (Of course, my bias is for language preservation) By that time the Russians and Tlingits were becoming more aquainted, so why did they sell off the land? The United States on the other hand wanted to civilize the Natives who they claimed were a part of the plants and fauna, not even human. They wanted to teach them to speak English because they couldn’t understand their languages, so then began the long drawn out saga of destruction for the Native people of Alaska.

(I hope the personal comments I made has not offended anyone. It is not meant to offend, but to share my opinions and bias.)

Tuesday, July 27, 2010

The Battle Over Who Gets What

I have to say, first, that this is a lot of information to take in and digest in a short period of time. There are so many complicated factors involved. I feel that no matter what decisions get made, Alaska will never be what it once was. Modern progress continues to weave its way through Alaska. I mourn for those who have had their cherished way of life ripped away from them. How does one successfully live in two worlds at the same time? Very few places if any, I presume, exist where life is lived completely in the old ways. Modern conveniences can make life easier in some respects, but it creates dependence on a cash economy. It seems like subsistence living has gone, for many, from being a pure means of survival to being a means of continuing a traditional way of life while, at the same time, being a way to earn money to pay for modern conveniences. What choice is there? How do people successfully move forward without letting go of their heritage, cultural identity?

As we discussed in class, regional corporations are given the responsibility to invest in way that will bring the greatest returns to its shareholders. Does money cure what ails? It may for some. For others it does more harm that good. In a perfect world those who want to continue to live the way they have for generations upon generations would be left to do so, undisturbed. In the real, savage world we live in its every man for himself so to speak. Those who have power decide the fate of others. Even those who start with the best intentions cannot fulfill the wants and needs of everyone.

So what is my point? Human beings have done great harm to other human beings by trying to civilize them. Nothing will truly make up for what has been lost. It is my opinion that regardless of what they agree to the Federal Government can do pretty much whatever it wants to. If the land was taken before it can be taken again. That is not to say that people should not continue to fight for what they feel is right, but there is probably never going to be an end to those battles.